How to hire executives for a tech company
To hire an executive, agree the business responsibility and authority you are ready to hand over, then assess candidates against that mandate. Settle the role yourself first, because a new leader cannot fix the business problem while the job itself is still undecided.
Agree what will change when the person joins
Name one decision that comes to you today and will belong to the executive once they start. Say who else it touches. If your team cannot agree on that handover, no candidate list will settle it.
Use the brief to make clear whether you want someone to lead a function or a senior specialist. A big title will not make up for a job without the authority the candidate expects. If you run it as a retained search, here is what to review at each stage of the executive search process.
Executive hiring decisions the founder owns
| Decision | What to establish before progressing |
|---|---|
| Mandate | The business responsibility the hire exists to own |
| Authority | The decisions the executive can make and the limits they work within |
| Assessment | The evidence each interviewer is responsible for checking |
| Appointment | Who makes the final call and how open concerns get resolved |
| Handover | The access and relationships the executive needs on day one |
Tell candidates what is difficult about the job
Tell candidates about the constraints they will inherit, including decisions you have already made. Someone who signs up for a rosier version of the role has every right to push back once they join. Get the hard facts on the table early.
Let candidates ask your team how the business really works. Their questions will show you gaps in the brief and help them decide whether the job is right for them.
Examine decisions under comparable conditions
Ask about a decision close to the work in your brief. Find out what the candidate did personally and what support they had at the time. Running a mature team is a different job from building the same function with almost nothing.
After each interview, write down what you still do not know. Use the next stage to answer those questions instead of having another broad chat about leadership style.
Make the appointment decision explicit
Give each interviewer one part of the role to assess and ask for the evidence behind their view. Argue out disagreements against the mandate. A loose show of hands tends to reward whoever made the best impression and leaves the hard questions unanswered.
With the candidate's agreement, use references to check the claims that matter most for this hire. Ask about a specific decision or working relationship, not just for a general recommendation.
Prepare to let the executive do the job
Tell your team about the new authority before the executive starts. If people can still go around the new hire whenever they dislike a decision, you have not really handed over the mandate.
Use CRO search for a broad revenue remit and CMO search for marketing leadership. Scalerr's executive search starts with scoping and supports the appointment through the guarantee period.
People also ask
Should a founder hire an executive before defining the strategy? Settle enough of the mandate that candidates know which strategic decisions they will own. An executive can help shape strategy, but they need clear authority and an honest account of what is already decided.
How many people should interview an executive? Pick interviewers based on the decisions and working relationships the role involves. Give each one a purpose and drop any meeting that would only repeat evidence you already have.
What if no candidate fits the brief? Look at what the search has taught you before you widen the requirements. The problem may be an unclear mandate or unrealistic assumptions about support, so find the cause before you lower the bar.
Brief us on this role through executive search, or use the enquiry form below.
Planning an executive hire?
Request a 20-minute GTM call. We will go through the mandate, the authority you are handing over and how to assess candidates against it.
Request a 20-minute GTM call