How to find a startup advisor

For founders looking for a startup advisor, start with a business decision you need help making and find someone who has handled a comparable problem. Approach them with that question, then check their judgement and availability before offering an advisory role.

By ·

This guide is for UK and US tech companies appointing advisors. A recognisable name can make the first conversation feel easy. You still need to find out what the person will contribute when your team is stuck on a difficult decision.

Write the problem before the profile

Describe what you are deciding now. A SaaS founder moving into enterprise accounts might need help understanding how a buyer gets approval. An AI founder might want someone to challenge the commercial case for a product evaluation. Those briefs point to different experience.

Write down what the team already knows and where it lacks evidence. Ask whether an advisor can contribute judgement on that gap. If the missing work is someone managing sellers every day, put the role into your GTM hiring plan and assess candidates for that responsibility.

Make the brief usable by the person introducing you. Explain the relevant customer and the decision you expect to make. They can then suggest an operator they have watched do the work, rather than forwarding a request for anyone with a senior title.

Where to find startup advisors

Look for people whose experience you can check. Use the route that gives you a reason to discuss the work with them.

RouteWhat to ask forWhat to check
Founders you trustAn introduction to someone who helped them with a comparable decision.What changed after the advice and how the person worked with the team.
Investors and existing board membersA relevant operator from companies they know.Whether the recommendation comes from direct experience and whether interests overlap.
Customers and experienced buyersA conversation about the buying process your team needs to understand.Permission to advise and any conflict with their current role.
Professional communities and eventsA follow-up with someone whose contribution addresses your specific problem.The work behind their public account and their own part in it.
A search firmA search against a written advisory brief.The people doing the search and how they will assess relevant experience.

HubSpot's advisory board guide, checked 16 November 2026, describes professional networks and industry events as ways to find prospective members. The questions in this table are ways to assess a referral, rather than evidence that one sourcing route always produces better advisors.

Approach a person with a question they can answer

Explain why their experience is relevant. Refer to the actual work you want to discuss and ask whether they are open to an initial conversation. Keep the first message short enough that they can judge the fit without asking you to explain the business from scratch.

For example: "We are deciding whether our next sales hire needs to have sold to enterprise finance teams. Your experience building that motion looks relevant. Are you open to a conversation about the buying assumptions in our brief?" Adapt the message to the person; a generic compliment adds little.

Say that you are exploring an advisory appointment if that is your intention. Let the person decide whether to have the discussion on that basis. Agree the scope before requesting substantial work, and avoid sending confidential customer material with an introductory message.

Test the advice against a real decision

Bring a concrete example with enough context for the candidate to question your assumptions. Explain what you have tried and the choice you face. Listen for what they need to know before recommending an answer.

Ask them to describe a comparable situation they handled. What did they decide personally? What did the rest of the team do? Where did their first view turn out to be wrong? Follow the details until you understand the judgement they contributed.

A useful advisor should be able to explain when their experience may not apply. A method that worked with an established product needs another look when you are still learning why customers buy. Ask what they would test in your situation before recommending the same approach.

Pay attention to how they respond when you disagree. Explain a constraint that makes their suggestion difficult and ask them to work through it with you. You need to know whether the conversation produces a clearer decision or stops once their initial answer is challenged.

Check references for work you can recognise

Ask permission to speak with founders or colleagues who saw the person contribute. Describe the advisory brief so the reference understands why you are asking. A general statement that someone is smart tells you little about how they will work with your team.

Ask about a decision they influenced and what happened afterwards. Find out whether they prepared, followed through on agreed actions and made time when a difficult question arose. If the reference describes an introduction, ask what involvement continued after it.

Separate what the reference observed from what they heard from others. Record any gap that needs another conversation with the candidate. An impressive company outcome should lead you to ask about the individual's role in it, especially when you are appointing them for that experience.

Check conflicts and time before agreeing the role

Ask about other advisory work and current employment that could affect the proposed relationship. A candidate may know your market because they work with a company pursuing the same buyers. Explain the information they would need to see and take uncertain conflicts to your legal adviser.

Discuss the preparation you expect as well as meetings. Ask how the person handles questions between scheduled calls and when they are unavailable. Put the expectation alongside their other commitments so both sides can judge whether the role is practical.

Keep advisory work separate from a formal director appointment. An advisor provides non-binding advice; a director takes on a different role and responsibilities. Use the board comparison guide if you are deciding which appointment the company needs.

Reasons to pause the appointment

Pause if the candidate promises customer access before understanding what you sell. Ask which relationship is relevant and what permission they would need for an introduction. Avoid treating a contact list as a commitment from the people on it.

Pause if they cannot describe their own contribution to the work on their profile. Give them a specific decision to explain and enough opportunity to answer. If the response stays at company-level achievements, you have not yet established the experience you are hiring for.

Also pause if the role expands every time you discuss it. Agree what you need now and what would require a new conversation. A narrow appointment with a clear review point is easier to assess than an open-ended promise to help with every problem.

Agree the first piece of work

Before appointing, set out the remit in an advisory board charter and have the written terms reviewed for your company. Include how advice will be requested and how either side can raise a problem with the arrangement. Discuss reward in that process without assuming the same terms suit every candidate.

Choose the first decision you will bring to the advisor and who inside the company owns the follow-up. Use how to build a startup advisory board for the wider appointment and operating plan. Review the relationship against the work agreed at the start.

People also ask

How do I find a startup advisor? Define the decision you need help with, then ask for introductions to people who have handled comparable work. Interview against that brief and check references before agreeing the appointment.

What makes a good startup advisor? Look for relevant experience and the ability to question your assumptions with specific evidence. Check whether they can prepare for the role and work through disagreement with the founder.

Should a startup advisor be a board member? An advisory appointment does not give someone a director's seat. Assess a proposed directorship separately and take advice on the formal responsibilities before making that appointment.

How do I approach a potential advisor? Explain the decision you face and why their experience appears relevant. Ask for an initial conversation, then agree the scope before requesting substantial work or sharing sensitive information.

Appointing an advisor or director?

Scalerr's Board & Exec Search covers board members, NEDs and advisors. Brief us on a board or advisor search, or use the form below to describe the appointment you are considering for your UK or US tech company.

Request a call

Brief us on a board or advisor search

By sending, you agree to be contacted by the Scalerr team about your enquiry.