← Back to blog
Recruitment · Colin Kleine ·

How to choose an executive search firm for tech

Choose an executive search firm by looking at how it would run your specific leadership search. Ask who will do the work and how the firm will turn your business problem into a candidate brief you can stand behind.

Give every firm the same business problem

Tell each firm what the executive will inherit and what you need to hand over. Include the decisions you have not made yet. If every firm hears a different version of the job, you will not be able to compare their proposals.

Ask what the firm would want to clarify before it approaches anyone. A firm that takes a vague title at face value has shown you how it will deal with ambiguity later in the search. To compare named firms and their published practices, see executive search firms for tech.

Questions to compare executive search firms

AskLook forResolve before appointment
Who will run the search?The names of the people doing the scoping, candidate work and updatesWhether the person pitching stays on the search
Where would you search for this mandate?A candidate market they can justify from the workWhether that pool fits your stage and your buyer
How will you assess candidates?Specific evidence against the agreed responsibilitiesWhat you and the firm each assess
What happens if the first response is weak?A way to review the brief against what the market saysWho can change the remit and how changes are recorded
What does the written scope include?Clear responsibilities through appointment and handoverConfidentiality, exclusions and any guarantee terms

Ask for comparable work without demanding confidential names

Ask about a search with a similar remit and a similar company. What you want to hear is how the firm scoped the role and judged candidates. A familiar client logo tells you neither.

Let the firm describe confidential work without naming the client or candidate. If they can offer a reference with permission, use the call to understand the process, not just to ask whether the client was happy.

Examine how candidate evidence reaches you

Ask what you will receive when the firm recommends a candidate. You should see the experience that matters for your mandate and the questions still open. A profile that repeats the CV leaves you to redo the assessment yourself.

Agree who interviews for what before the shortlist arrives. You and the firm should each know which claims you are checking and how concerns get resolved.

Discuss conflicts and confidentiality directly

Ask whether any client commitments stop the firm approaching part of your candidate market. Find out what that means in practice for your search. Do not assume every firm can approach everyone.

If the search is sensitive, agree how the role will be described and who gets to see information. Put those responsibilities in the written scope so everyone works from the same version.

Compare scope before making the decision

Read what happens if the mandate changes or the appointment does not work out. Get exclusions and aftercare in writing. A guarantee can mean different things in different proposals.

Scalerr's executive search includes mandate scoping and a senior-led process through the guarantee period. Use the recruiting service comparison to check which model fits, and the sales recruitment agency guide for the same choice in sales hiring.

People also ask

Should I choose a firm from a ranking? Use a list to start, then test each firm against your search. A ranking will not tell you who runs the work or whether their candidate market fits your mandate.

Does a firm need to have filled the exact same title? Similar responsibility in a similar company counts for more than a matching title. Ask how the earlier search relates to the decisions your new executive will own.

What should be agreed before signing a proposal? Agree the mandate, who does what in the search and how decisions get made. Read the written scope for confidentiality, exclusions and any guarantee terms before you appoint the firm.

Brief us on this role through executive search, or use the enquiry form below.

Comparing executive search firms?

Request a 20-minute GTM call. We will tell you how we would scope and run your search, so you can compare it with the other proposals.

Request a 20-minute GTM call

Brief us on this role

By sending, you agree to be contacted by the Scalerr team about your enquiry.