What is a headhunter, and how is it different from a recruiter?
A headhunter is a recruiter who approaches people who are not looking for a new job and persuades the strongest of them to consider your role; agency recruiters, contingent search firms and retained executive search firms all headhunt, and they differ in how they are paid, how widely they search and which hires they suit.
Which model to use depends on the role in front of you. A first account executive, a Head of Sales and a CRO usually call for three different arrangements.
What is a headhunter?
Headhunting means direct approach. The recruiter builds a list of people doing the job well at other companies, contacts them, and explains why your role might be worth a conversation. Most strong sales and marketing leaders are employed and hitting their numbers, so few of them are browsing job adverts.
The word describes an activity, so on its own it tells you little about the arrangement. A solo recruiter on LinkedIn, a large agency and a retained executive search partner can all call themselves headhunters. Before you agree anything, ask how they are paid, whether they work the role exclusively and who will make the approaches.
How do a headhunter, an agency recruiter and an executive search firm compare?
| Independent headhunter | Agency recruiter (contingent) | Retained executive search firm | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical roles | Specialist or senior roles in a niche the person knows well | Individual contributor and first-line manager roles, often several at once | VP, C-level and board roles, and senior hires with a broad remit |
| How candidates are found | Personal network and direct approach | Candidate database, job adverts and direct approach | A map of the target companies, then confidential direct approach |
| How they are paid | Varies, so ask before you start | A fee only when you hire a candidate they introduced | In stages, starting when the search begins |
| Exclusivity | Varies | Usually not exclusive; several agencies may work the same role | Exclusive for the length of the search |
| What you receive | A small number of personal introductions | CVs, often within days | A calibrated shortlist, market feedback, references and offer support |
| Best fit | A hard-to-reach niche where one person has the network | A role with a clear profile and many qualified people in the market | A leader whose hire changes the revenue plan or the direction of the company |
What is the difference between a headhunter and a recruiter?
A recruiter fills roles. Some do it mostly from inbound applicants and a candidate database; others spend most of their time approaching people who have not applied. "Headhunter" usually means the second kind. The difference is how much of the work is direct approach and how well the recruiter knows the people in your market.
For go-to-market roles, that knowledge shows in the first call. A recruiter who hires sales leaders every week will ask about your sales motion, deal size and sales cycle, and whether the hire inherits a team or builds one. A generalist may ask only for the job description. What a GTM recruiter does covers this specialism in more detail.
Is an executive search firm the same as a headhunter?
An executive search firm headhunts, and it also runs a fuller process for senior hires. It agrees a written mandate, maps the companies where suitable leaders work, approaches them confidentially, assesses them against the mandate, and supports the offer and the first months in the job. Most searches are retained and exclusive, which gives the firm time to cover the whole market before it puts anyone in front of you.
The payment model changes the incentives. A contingent recruiter earns a fee only when you hire someone they introduced, so speed pays. A retained firm is paid to complete the search, so it can afford to tell you when the brief or the package does not match what the market will accept. Retained vs contingent search compares the two models for GTM roles, and what is executive search walks through each stage of a search.
Should I use a headhunter to hire a sales leader?
Yes, in most cases. The people who can run a sales team at your stage are usually employed and well paid, and they are not reading job boards, so someone has to approach them. The choice is which kind of headhunter to use, and that depends on seniority and on how much the hire will change.
- A first account executive or sales manager with a clear profile suits a specialist recruiter on a focused search. Scalerr's Key Talent Search fills these roles in 21 days on average.
- A Head of Sales or VP Sales who will build the team and own the number suits a specialist headhunter or a retained search, depending on how scarce the profile is.
- A CRO, a CMO or a country manager opening a new market suits a retained executive search. Scalerr's senior searches take 6 to 10 weeks.
Scalerr hires sales, marketing, partnerships, customer success and revenue leaders for tech, SaaS and AI companies from Pre-Seed to Series C and beyond. It does not recruit engineers. The firm has made 2,000+ placements and supported 500+ startups and scale-ups from six offices in Australia, Singapore, Korea, the UK, the US and the UAE. Senior hires go through Board & Exec Search, which starts with a scoping session and runs through to offer and aftercare. For revenue leadership roles in particular, see sales executive search.
What should you ask a headhunter before you start?
Ask questions whose answers you can check later:
- Who will approach candidates, and how will they describe your company and the role?
- Which companies will they search, and which are off limits because they are current clients?
- How will they assess a sales leader: which evidence, which references, and who runs each interview?
- What happens if the hire leaves early, and is that written into the agreement?
- How often will you hear what the market is saying about the role, the package and the shortlist?
The answers to the second and fourth questions belong in writing. A firm that recruits from your competitors' customers, or from companies you sell to, needs to say so before the search starts.
People also ask
Is a headhunter the same as a recruiter? No, not always. Every headhunter recruits, but many recruiters work mainly from applicants and their own database. A headhunter spends most of the search approaching people who have not applied.
Who pays the headhunter? The hiring company pays. A candidate should never be charged for an introduction to a role. When and how the company pays depends on whether the search is contingent or retained.
Can I use more than one headhunter for the same role? Yes, if the role is on a contingent basis, but the same candidates may then hear about your role from several recruiters with different stories. A retained search is exclusive, so one firm owns the approach and the message.
How long does a headhunter take to hire a sales leader? It depends on seniority. Scalerr fills specialist GTM roles in 21 days on average through Key Talent Search, and its senior executive searches take 6 to 10 weeks.
Brief us on this role through executive search, or use the enquiry form below.
Not sure the role needs executive search?
Some senior hires need a retained search; others suit Key Talent Search. Request a 20-minute GTM call and we'll help you scope the role honestly.
Request a 20-minute GTM call